Critique Super Mario Galaxy The Movie

Note: This review is guaranteed spoiler-free.

Yoshi in trouble?

“Super Mario Galaxy: The Movie” is not meant to tell a deep story or have multiple layers of meaning. Just like Nintendo, which prioritizes gameplay pleasure over lore and timelines, the animated film aims to simply provide a fun experience with a mix of stunts, jokes, and fun.

If you are expecting an adaptation to fill in narrative gaps from the video game saga or deliver an emotional Pixar-style epic, this may not be for you. The film fully embraces its video game DNA and prefers to draw inspiration from Nintendo game mechanics and pace rather than typical family movie codes. While movies based on video game licenses like Sonic work well with conventional adventure film formulas, Nintendo and Illumination’s choice to take a different route shows that success can still be achieved with a faithful, unique, and surprisingly free adaptation unlike any other.

In terms of plot, the film maintains the essence of the saga with a princess to rescue, but this time the game takes place across an intergalactic setting inspired directly by the “Super Mario Galaxy” games. A fast-paced adventure through the stars unfolds to thwart the plans of the new antagonist, Bowser Jr. The film also broadens its character palette by introducing several iconic figures from the Nintendo universe, with Yoshi and Rosalina in the spotlight.

While some characters may have limited screen time that could be frustrating, each manages to leave an impression. The brotherly dynamic between Mario and Luigi remains strong, and the father-son relationship between Bowser and Bowser Jr. cleverly balances tenderness and comedy. Yoshi stands out as one of the coolest characters in the film, closely followed by Fox McCloud with a surprisingly effective cameo. It is a shame that Nintendo revealed Star Fox’s presence beforehand, as the surprise could have had a bigger impact, but it’s understandable from a promotional standpoint.

A film that doesn’t go beyond its Peach

For fans of “Super Mario Galaxy” who appreciated the emotional story of Rosalina, expectations might have been higher compared to “Super Mario Bros: The Movie.” The emotional tale (completely optional in the game) attempted to bring depth and meaning to the character, touching on themes like grief and loneliness. This vision, led by Yoshiaki Koizumi (director of Super Mario Galaxy), contrasts with Shigeru Miyamoto’s desire to maintain a simple universe avoiding heavy interpretations. This approach, reflected in “Super Mario Galaxy 2,” serves as a primary model for this film.

While a more melancholic approach could have been intriguing, it’s the creator’s vision that prevails. The film maintains a light and consistently entertaining tone, never taking itself too seriously, except for one revelation that may stir lore fans. However, the second half of the film may feel a bit disjointed, veering in different directions. While the energetic mix remains digestible thanks to strong action and comedy, it can get chaotic at times. The numerous cameos are enjoyable but may also give a sense of overload.

The ending may seem rushed, lacking in transitions. The film could have benefited from more time to let the events breathe and conclude the adventure. The fast-paced nature may give the impression of a film tailored for a “TikTok generation” with limited attention spans. However, it’s better seen as an attempt to capture the dynamic nature of Mario games, known for their fast-paced action.

On the other hand, “Super Mario Galaxy: The Movie” enhances its strengths compared to the first film with more inventive action sequences, sharper humor, and unwavering respect for the Nintendo universe.

Less pop songs and more OST

One aspect that nearly everyone agrees on is the quality of animation provided by Illumination. The visual spectacle is accompanied by vibrant artistic direction and a variety of galactic environments. This aesthetic richness blends with remarkable attention to detail, staying true to the Nintendo universe in every frame. A second viewing may be necessary, as even in the subtlest backgrounds, unexpected references can be spotted.

Despite the visual overload mentioned earlier, the film maintains technical excellence, strong direction, and inventive set design. The most significant evolution from “Super Mario Bros: The Movie” lies in the musical atmosphere. While the game franchise boasts beloved compositions, the accumulation of pop songs in the previous movie did not do justice to Mario’s musical legacy. Brian Tyler’s orchestral arrangements, incorporating iconic game themes, seamlessly fit the big screen format. The sound fan service is perfectly balanced, carrying emotional weight in key moments.

Lastly, the French dubbing deserves praise for its vocal performance, holding its own against American stars.

“Super Mario Galaxy: The Movie” is a generous, colorful, and genuinely funny spectacle that prioritizes pure entertainment over narrative ambition. This choice may not appeal to everyone but aligns with Nintendo’s philosophy and maintains consistency with the first film. Despite occasional pacing issues and a rushed conclusion, the film compensates with undeniable technical mastery and a spectacular adventure from start to finish. The adaptation’s greatest success lies in appealing to both longtime fans and the general audience (slightly less so for demanding cinephiles). A remarkable achievement.